|
Rega
R5 Review at AVReview.co.uk
Jason Kennedy
July, 2005
While Southend's finest hi-fi
company may have started out as a turntable specialist in 1973 with
the Planet and its distinctive three-armed platter,
nowadays Rega produces a complete range of stereo components including
cables, CD players and loudspeakers. As yet founder Roy Gandy has
not found a reason to enter the multichannel market
primarily because he can't see what it's got to do with music. Each
to his own...
The R5 is what the company describes
as a medium floorstander, it looks quite cute to me but then I don't
have to accommodate the tastes of other householders,
not in the listening room at least. Standing just over 80cm
high without spikes this is an attractive and none too intrusive
speaker whose biggest drive unit is located on the side,
thereby keeping the front profile slim.
The middle model in a range of
five, the R5 is in essence a three-way speaker, albeit one that
is cleverly designed not to require crossover components
to tailor the output of the 130mm bass cone. This relies on mechanical
roll-off to achieve integration with the 90mm coned midrange driver.
The bass unit features a six-layer
aluminium voice coil which reduces mass and combines with the paper
cone to produce low notes down to an unspecified frequency
- unusually Rega does not specify a low frequency roll-off.
This is probably because it is aware that the bass extension of
any speaker is dependent on the nature and positioning
within any given environment, and figures achieved under laboratory
conditions are rarely accurate for domestic situations.
Sorry, but it's true.
Rega suggests that the R5 can
be placed against a wall and while it accepts that conventional
thinking would say that the bass drivers should face
outwards its recommendation is that the user should experiment with
both options to find the best approach for a given environment.
We got a bigger sound when firing outwards but achieved
a better focused and preferable result with an inward orientation.
This speaker is equipped with
bi-wire terminals but according to Rega's literature this will
offer no advantage, so presumably they have been
included because of the demands of the market at this price point
rather than just for the heck of it. The twin terminals arrive connected
by gold-plated bars but these are best replaced with
speaker cable if sound quality is a concern. If you're in any doubt,
just compare the two - the difference isn't subtle.
Performance
The majority of loudspeakers at the more affordable
price points tend to have a fairly safe and sensible balance
- they pump up the bass a little and smooth off the treble so that
they sound bigger than they really are and not too challenging.
Rega's R5 eschews this approach and gives you an uncompromised version
of events, which means that it sounds distinctly different
right from the off - there is a dryness to the presentation
that makes for an explicit and upfront but not bright musical experience.
This is a highly engaging loudspeaker
that's not satisfied until it gets you leaping about the room. It
does this primarily by getting the timing spot on, and
as a result other factors like dynamics, timbral resolve and imaging
take a back seat. Not so far back as to suggest it fails to communicate
these qualities but enough to give the impression that
the designer considers them less important. On the evidence presented
it's hard to disagree.
Communication of the musical
message is very good, whether that be the groove of Third Face or
the laments of Gillian Welch, the R5 takes you to the
nub of the music. Occasionally, as with the former, it can sound
a little coarse - this is not the smoothest speaker around. But
more often, as with Ms Welch, you hear the emotional
power of the song so loud and clear as to be transported - which
after all is what music should be all about.
It's very good with steel strung
guitars though, sounding more like the real thing than plenty of
more expensive designs, and it brings out the 'liveness'
in almost any recording. It also differentiates well between recordings,
right down to individual album tracks in fact. This is probably
a reflection of the balance though and not high resolution
per se. Occasionally you get a record that does not suit the R5's
approach, notably Keith Jarrett's piano on Bremen Lausanne
which lacks body, sounding tinny and hard. There is a leanness to
the speaker which inevitably won't suit all music or tastes and
anyone who prefers a really sumptuous
sound is reading the wrong review. The rest of you, though,
should consider an audition.
Verdict:
Anyone wishing to get the most musical enjoyment for
their money from a speaker that does bass and doesn't
need a stand should do their utmost to try out the R5. It has the
best communication skills we've heard from a sub thousand
pound speaker in a long time.
Plus points:
Superb musical communication
Decent bass extension for size and the ability to be wall
mounted
Real wood veneer
Minus points:
A bit dry and lean for some tastes
Tonally better with electric guitars than pianos
|