|
Rega
R1 Review at StereoTimes.com
By Paul Szabady
December, 2005
Ive always had the deepest
respect for Rega. They have, since their inception, never lost sight
of their ideals: making affordable components that truly
deliver the music. Their refreshing attitude towards marketing
(no advertising/no hype, reliance on word of mouth to earn their
reputation,) company structure (non-hierarchical and
without the militaristic pyramid structure of authority) further
endear them to me, but it is the way they create products
that marks them as special. They actually listen to their products
and base their design decisions on whether the product
truly satisfies their musical jones. Making the demands
of music their prime design consideration strikes me
as the proper relationship between technology and music. That
Regas products get the music so right and at prices the average
music lover might actually be willing to spend makes
me seriously question the existential justification for High End
items that cant even get basic rhythms right.
Its got a bad beat, and even James Brown couldnt
dance to it in the old American Bandstand record-rating
terminology.
Rega is, of course, best known
for their turntables and tonearms, products that have so dominated
the market that the Rega tonearm geometry has become
the default geometry for most other tables and arms. In some
ways this success is unfortunate, as it overshadows Regas
other outstanding products and their larger goal of
creating complete music systems, each component of which is designed
to work harmoniously with the others to achieve the
same direct and satisfying musical result. I reviewed a complete
Rega complete system (Rega system) and found that to
truly appreciate what Rega is doing musically you really must hear
all their components playing together. As good as the
individual components are, they are even better when heard
in the organic and holistic context of like-minded Rega products.
The musical result is so direct and so satisfying that
music lovers can easily avoid the darker aspects of the High End/Audiophile
obsession.
Much of Regas time recently
has been spent in the design and development of their new R
series of loudspeakers, of which the bookshelf/stand-mount
R1, at $495 a pair, is the least expensive. There are 5 speakers
in the line, the other 4 being floor standers, priced at $795, $1195,
$2495, and topping out with their flagship R9 at $3995
a pair. All the speakers were designed in-house and are manufactured
in England. Rega designed and manufactures the individual
drivers, a unique departure from the current speaker
manufacturer norm, where a company buys OEM drivers, slaps them
in a box, and uses sweatshop Chinese labor to manufacture
them for pennies. The R series is no run-of-the-mill
speaker line. The time, care, and attention paid to
the demands of producing music right have paid off: the R1 hits
the musical nail squarely on the head.
At the heart of the R series
is Regas new RR125 mid/bass driver, a 125 mm paper cone unit
of superb transient speed, timing accuracy, clarity
and resolution. The R1 uses the RR125 in a small, genuine wood veneered
box of mini-monitor (12.5 Hx10Dx6 W) dimensions.
The woofer is reflex-loaded at the back of the R1s
cabinet and is mounted at the top of the cabinet, above the Rega
tweeter. Speaker load is benign; Rega quotes a sensitivity
of 90 dB. Any good, musically competent solid-state amplifier of
30 watts per channel (for starters Regas own Brio
comes to mind) should be able to drive the R1s in the
smaller-room applications for which it was designed.
Speaker break-in was typical,
with bass response and subtle dynamic tracking being the last aspects
of performance to flower, these last fully occurring
at about 40 hours of play. Regas owner manual doesnt
make any specific recommendations as far as speaker
placement and set-up goes. This may strike one as cavalier
until one realizes that the goal of the speaker musical involvement
occurs with even casual
set-up. Fully optimizing its performance is up to the user,
should they require it, and the speaker fully responds.
The R1 is small enough to be actually used on a bookshelf (remember
when monsters like the Large Advent and AR 3a were called
bookshelf speakers?) as well as on speaker stands. Toe-in doesnt
seem critical, nor does speaker stand type. This was
especially true since I use the Stillpoints to isolate all my
speakers from their stands: the stand then becomes immaterial. Speaker
height is critical however, as the R1s tweeter
is located below the woofer: too high a placement will keep the
tweeter from integrating with the mid/bass driver. I
tried the R1 in 3 different rooms, with 3 different grades of equipment
resolution, and with set-ups ranging from the slothfully
maladroit to the classic mini-monitor small room set-up. The R1
was truly musically involving in all these configurations;
perfectionist small-room mini-monitor set-up allowed the speaker
to project truly hallucinatory stereo illusions in addition to its
music making abilities.
Immediate impressions are a clear
and transparent portrayal with very high detail retrieval, fast
and controlled transient response, and superb musical
timing, both in articulating rhythms and tempi, and in placing
instruments within the temporal flow and context of the performance.
The RR125 is an outstanding mid/bass driver, sonically
and musically right in line with the midrange performance of Regas
amplifiers and phono cartridges. Get the midrange right
and everything else will fall into place. Get it wrong, and all
the kings horses
When auditioned with the R1s
woofer at ear height or lower, the R1s tweeter has a slight
time delay to the ear compared to the RR125. The sonic
effect of this is an integration of the tweeter with the RR125 mid/bass
unit so well done that it sounds like the R1 is using a single driver.
Higher frequency harmonics emanate from the position
of the instrument rather than from a detached artificial space above
it, yet high frequency percussion placed high in the
sound field is perceived as such. The tweeter itself is as exceptional
a performer as the RR125, its speed and transient resolution
allowing one not only to hear the signatures of cymbals
and other high frequency percussion, but also to hear how they are
being played, and most crucial of all, to hear their
rhythmic patterns. Rega quotes no crossover point for the R1. I
was unable to identify it by ear: the sonic and musical
coherence of the 2 drivers is exceptional.
Rega has always excelled at coaxing
surprising amounts of clear bass from their small bass drivers.
The R1s bass response is very clearly articulated
and is as fast and rhythmically coherent as the rest of the bandwidth.
Users can expect flat response in-room to at least 80 Hz (in my
small room classic
mini-monitor set-up, the 3dB point was 63 Hz) with
some additional reinforcement available by room size, building
construction rigidity, and speaker positioning. Bass lines are extremely
easy to follow: the R1 passed my acid test of The Ron
Carter Quartets Piccolo, clearly separating Carters
piccolo bass from Buster Williams lower pitched
standard acoustic bass AND articulating what they were doing musically
and rhythmically. Considering that Ive heard $7,000
to $10,000 speakers flub this recording, the R1s performance
is stellar. Low bass rolls off steeply due to the reflex-loading
of the RR125 of course, but in small rooms in particular,
articulate and detailed bass is far more musically communicative
than opaque
boom and thud. Quality trumps quantity every time. Like
some other truly excellent small speakers, some of
the lower bass is phantom bass; the R1s
speed and transient control reproduces the 2nd and 3rd harmonics
of a bass note so well that one can both identify and place the
instrument in the sound field, even though the 30 to
60 Hz range where the fundamental note is placed might be down in
absolute level.
One could of course try to augment
the R1s bass response by adding a subwoofer. To be successful
the subwoofer would have to match the R1s fleetness
of foot and would have to have a steep crossover
roll-off so that the subwoofers mid-bass response would
not interfere with that of the R1. Particularly in small
rooms, this is unlikely to succeed. It makes more sense to move
up to the Rega R3 or R5 speakers with their larger cabinets
and additional bass drivers ($795 and $1195) if ones room
is too big to allow the R1s bass response to convince.
Unlike many inexpensive speakers,
the R1 is a very high-resolution device. It is not dumbed-down
to flatter less able partners or mediocre recordings,
nor does it partake of the old British stereotype of too stiff an
upper lip reticence. It handles nuance and exuberance equally well.
It is capable of revealing differences in electronics
and sources that less capable and opaque designs simply cannot resolve.
In this aspect of performance, the R1 can become analytical.
The solution is to audition the R1 in the context of a complete
Rega system whose overall nature is integrative and
organic. Still, even with my humblest auditioning system (a
1970s Connoisseur BD2a turntable and Marantz 1060 integrated
amp surely qualify as humble enough) the R1s extracted
the musical message unambiguously, relayed the acoustic in which
instruments originated, and created a 3-dimensional
sound field that eliminated any perceptual effort at orientation.
It was clear, however, that R1 was capable of more than
this system was producing, and further auditioning at 3 higher resolution
levels showed the R1 to be completely at ease.
Not surprisingly given Regas
strong turntable background, the R1s really shine with LP
playback, creating that deep sense of rhythmic and musical
flow that is the LPs forte. I used the R1s in my recent
review of the Graham Slee Elevator EXP and Era Gold
V phono preamps and found it able to reveal sonic and musical
differences in phono sections, arms, cartridges and turntables.
Not to the degree of my Sound Lab Dynastat big room
reference speakers, of course, but remember that this is a $500
entry-level product. There is something
deeply satisfying about a reasonably priced speaker able to make
such fine discriminations.
High resolution, detail, and
fleetness of foot do not always guarantee musical communication
however. It is the ability to organize the sound into
comprehensible and meaningful patterns that is the gist of successful
music making, both in actual live performance and in
audio reproduction. Punctuation, emphasis and
de-emphasis, and the organization of time are crucial here.
This area has been the province of British products
in general, and Rega products in particular, almost exclusively
for most of the last 30 years: the R1 continues Regas
noble tradition. It makes musical sense of a wide variety of types
of music, leading quickly to an immersion into the music
rather than to a distracting awareness of the sound of the speaker.
This is as it should be, and is part of Regas
long-standing design philosophy: Listen to the music. Quit obsessing
about the sound!
I have always been more impressed
by inexpensive speakers that deliver the music than I have by
cost-no-object designs. It takes far more design intelligence
and a deeper awareness of the demands of music to produce
a coherent budget design. It seems, in fact, that the more expensive
the dynamic-driver speaker, the less likely it is get
the basics of music right. Forget rubato, forget revealing in
the pocket drumming, or articulating polyrhythms:
most of the over-priced dynamic-driver speaker monstrosities cant
even lay out a simple 4/4 beat. They too often play
as if they were musical illiterates. That inexpensive speakers
can get the basics of timing, phrasing and punctuation right creates
a difficult existential crisis for mega-buck speakers
that cant. For this reason I have always kept a budget reference
speaker around.
The Rega R1 becomes my new budget
reference speaker. In addition of its ability to get the fundamentals
of music right, it adds clarity and resolution, and
an ability to lay out a vivid and coherent 3-dimensional stereo
image. In small room applications, what more could you want.
|
|